March 2011
Dear Member of Congress,
We understand that due to growing federal deficit, we are entering a period of significant cuts to non-security discretionary spending. At a time when America's economic survival and global competitiveness is at stake, while child poverty in America is also soaring, we consider cuts to Head Start and Early Head Start extremely short-sighted. As researchers, we offer some facts about Head Start that are worth remembering:
Head Start improves the odds and the options for at-risk kids for a lifetime. Kids that have been through Head Start and Early Head Start are healthier, more academically accomplished, more likely to be employed, commit fewer crimes, and contribute more to society.
Simply put: Head Start works. It's been proven.
Studies of Head Start programs found that Head Start increases educational achievement: raising test scores, decreasing the need for children to receive special education services and making it less likely that children will repeat a grade.[i] Head Start graduates are also more likely to graduate from high school and attend college.[ii]
Head Start's impact on child health is impressive. Likely because of its required medical screenings, vaccinations, and emphasis on nutrition, Head Start reduces by as much as 50 percent the mortality rates for 5- to 9-year-olds.[iii] A Head Start child is 19 to 25 percent less likely to smoke as an adult.[iv] And Head Start parents receiving health literacy decreased annual Medicaid costs by $232 per family.[v]
Head Start graduates are 12 percent less likely to be booked or charged with a crime.[vi] This reduction translates into savings for crime victims, local, state, and federal governments, and the American taxpayer.
The National Impact Study of Head Start found that children attending Head Start made significant cognitive and socio-emotional gains compared with the control group children during the Head Start year and were in better health compared to the control group children.[vii]
And it's not just the at-risk kids who benefit. Head Start and Early Head Start also provide improved parenting skills and practices.[viii] Head Start's emphasis on parental involvement contributes to the upward mobility of Head Start parents by helping to move them out of poverty,[ix] and that Early Head Start parents are much more likely to participate in job training programs and more likely to have a job.[x] At a time when unemployment rate is hovering close to 10%, Head Start and Early Head Start are critical gateways to employment.
As the 112th Congress evaluates domestic discretionary spending, we urge you to look at the substantial research showing that Head Start and Early Head Start programs have a long history of not only being a wise investment and saving local, state, and federal taxpayers money but also a critical safety net for our most vulnerable citizens.
Multiple studies demonstrate that Head Start is an astoundingly smart investment. For every $1 invested in Head Start, we get a Return On Investment (ROI) ranging from $7 to $9.[xi] As James Heckman, a Nobel Laureate in Economics at the University of Chicago, recommended to the National Commission on Fiscal Responsibility and Budget Reform: "Early Head Start and Head Start are programs on which to build and improve-not to cut."[xii] That's why we ask that Congress to provide $8.2 billion in Fiscal Years 2011 and 2012 to ensure that Head Start and Early Head Start can maintain their current enrollment levels.
Sincerely,
Edward Zigler, Ph.D.
| Kathleen McCartney, Ph.D. Dean & Gerald S. Lesser Professor in Early Childhood Development Harvard Graduate School of Education Harvard University | Mary Abbott, Ph.D. Associate Research Scientist University of Kansas | ||
Linda Albi, M.S.
| LaRue Allen, Ph.D. Professor New York University | Jennifer Astuto, Ph.D. Assistant Director, Assistant Research Professor Child and Family Policy Center, Department of Applied Psychology New York University | ||
| Jane Atwater, Ph.D Assistant Research Professor University of Kansas | Stephen J. Bagnato, Ed.D.
| Jessica V. Barnes, Ph.D. Associate Director of University-Community Partnerships Michigan State University | ||
| Steven Barnett, Ph.D. Co-Director National Institute for Early Education Research Rutgers University | Sandra Barrueco, Ph.D.
| Lauren Barton, Ph.D. | ||
| Diane Becker, NCCJTS, ILCSW Founder Avenue For Change | Linda S. Beeber, Ph.D., APRN-BC, FAAN
| Katherine Renee Behring, M.Ed Early Childhood Education Consultant University Settlement | ||
| Lisa Berlin, Ph.D. Research Scientist Duke University | Ilene Berson, Ph.D. Professor of Early Childhood Education University of South Florida | Kathryn Bigelow, Ph.D.
| ||
| Charles Bleiker, Ph.D. Associate Professor Florida International University | Mary Boat, Ph.D.
| Patti Bokony, Ph.D. Assistant Professor University of Arkansas for Medical Sciences | ||
Rosemary Bolig, Ph.D.
| Neil W. Boris, M.D. Professor Tulane University | John Borkowski, Ph.D. Research Professor of Psychology Andrew J. McKenna Family University of Notre Dame | ||
Kelly K. Bost, Ph.D. | Lisa Boyce, Ph.D. Research Assistant Professor Utah State University | Isabel Bradburn, Ph.D.Research Director, Child Development Center for Learning and Research Virginia Tech University
| ||
Robert Bradley, Ph.D.Professor Arizona State University | Linda Brekken, Ph.D.
| Christopher Brown, Ph.D.Assistant Professor of Political Science | ||
David L. Brown, Ph.D.
| Jan Brown, M.Ed. | Holly Elissa Bruno, J.D. Adjunct Professor Wheelock College | ||
| Deborah A. Bruns, Ph.D. Associate Professor Southern Illinois University of Carbondale | Margaret Burchinal, Ph.D.
| Barbara M. Burns, Ph.D. Professor University of Louisville | ||
| M. Susan Burns, Ph.D. Associate Professor George Mason University | Virginia Buysse, Ph.D.
| Victoria Carr, Ed.D. Associate Professor University of Cincinnati | ||
| Judith Carta, Ph.D. Senior Scientist/Professor Juniper Gardens Children’s Project University of Kansas | Dina C. Castro, Ph.D.
| Eun Kyeong Cho, Ed.D.Assistant Professor University of New Hampshire | ||
| Audrey Clark, Ph.D. Professor Emeritus California State University Northridge | Jantina Clifford, Ph.D. Assistant Professor University of Oregon | Richard M. Clifford, Ph.D.
| ||
| David Cohen Director Education, Research & Outreach Sesame Workshop | Cynthia Garcia Coll, Ph.D.
| Marliee Comfort, Ph.D. Partner Parenting Assessment Research & Development & Dissemination Comfort Consults, LLC | ||
Nicola Conners-Burrow, Ph.D.
| Gina A. Cook, Ph.D. Research Scientist Utah State University | Rob Corso, Ph.D. Assistant Research Professor Vanderbilt University | ||
| Leslie Couse, Ph.D. Associate Professor of Early Childhood Education University of New Hampshire | Diane Craft, Ph.D.
| Danielle Crosby, Ph.D. Assistant Professor University of North Carolina at Greensboro | ||
| Flavio Cunha, Ph.D. Assistant Professor University of Pennsylvania | Janet Currie, Ph.D.
| Lois-ellin Datta, Ph.D. President Datta Analysis | ||
Andrea DeBruin-Parecki, Ph.D.
| Michelle DeKlyen, Ph.D. Associate Research Scholar Princeton University | Susanne A. Denham, Ph.D. Professor Department of Psychology George Mason University | ||
| Sarah Dennis, Ph.D Facilitator with the New Schools Project Erikson Institute | Cynthia DiCarlo, Ph.D. Associate Professor Louisiana State University | Susan Dickstein, Ph.D.
| ||
Laurie Dinnebeil, Ph.D.
| Sebreana Domingue Research Associate UL Lafayette | Catherine Donahue, Ed.D. Associate Professor Wheelock College | ||
Anne Douglass, Ph.D. | Jason Downer, Ph.D. Senior Research Scientist University of Virginia | Marilyn C. Dumont-Driscoll, Ph.D., M.D. Associate Professor University of Florida College of Medicine | ||
Carolyn Pope Edwards, Ed.D.
| Kristen Ehrhardt, Ph.D. | Pam Elwood, Ph.D. Consultant of EC Kent State University | ||
Richard Fabes, Ph.D.
| Richard Faldowski, Ph.D. Associate Professor University of North Carolina at Greensboro | Beverly Falk, Ed.D. | ||
Michaela L. Z. Farber, M.S.W., Ph.D.
| Edward G. Feil, Ph.D. Senior Research Scientist Oregon Research Institute | Jason Kane Feld, Ph.D. Vice President Corporate Projects Assessment Technology, Inc. | ||
| Anne L. Fetter, Ph.D. Scientifically Based Researcher Research Consulting & Design | Richard Fiene, Ph.D. Professor of Human Development and Family Studies & Psychology Penn State University | Barbara H. Fiese, Ph.D.
| ||
Janet Filer, Ph.D.
| Hiram E. Fitzgerald, Ph.D. Associate Provost and University Distinguished Professor Michigan State University | Roseanne L. Flores, Ph.D. Associate Professor Hunter College of the City University of New York | ||
| Susan Fowler, Ph.D. Professor University of Illinois | Ellen Frede, Ph.D.
| David Frisvold, Ph.D. Assistant Professor of Economics Emory University | ||
Victoria R. Fu, Ph.D.
| Michael Fultz, Ed.D. Associate Professor University of Wisconsin-Madison | Kathleen Cranley Gallagher, Ph.D.
| ||
| Sukhdeep Gill, Ph.D. Associate Professor Pennsylvania State University | Walter Gilliam, Ph.D. | Herbert P. Ginsburg, Ph.D. Professor of Psychology and Education Jacoh H. Schiff Foundation Teachers College Columbia University | ||
| Mark R. Ginsberg, Ph.D. Dean and Professor College of Education and Human Development George Mason University | Marika Ginsburg-Block, Ph.D.
| Carla B. Goble, Ph.D. Professor of Child Development George Kaiser Family Endowed Tulsa Community Colleg | ||
Michael K. Godfrey, Ph.D.
| Phil Gordon, Ph.D. Partner Comfort Consults, LLC. | Sandra Graham-Bermann, Ph.D. Professor of Psychology and Psychiatry University of Michigan | ||
| Liane Grayson, Ph.D. Senior Research Analyst Minnesota Department of Human Services | Beth Green, Ph.D.
| Katy Gregg, Ph.D. Assistant Professor Georgia Southern University | ||
| Carolyn Griess, Ph.D. (ABD) Faculty Penn State University | Jennifer Grisham-Brown, Ed.D.
| Christina J. Groark, Ph.D. Co-director, Office of Child Development University of Pittsburgh | ||
Judy Grossman, Ph.D.
| Alison Wishard Guerra, Ph.D. Assistant Professor UC San Diego | Sarika S. Gupta, Ph.D. Postdoctoral Fellow Early Childhood Special Education Leadership/Policy University of Colorado Denver | ||
| Trevor Hadley, Ph.D. Professor of Psychology and Psychiatry University of Pennsylvania | Rena Hallam, Ph.D.
| Brenda Jones Harden, Ph.D. Associate Professor University of Maryland | ||
| Sanna Harjusola-Webb, Ph.D. Assistant Professor Kent State University | Martha Elizabeth Harmon, M.A. Writer and Consultant Research for Different Educational Facilities | Thelma Harms, Ph.D.
| ||
Kathleen Hebbeler, Ph.D. | Mary Louise Hemmeter, Ph.D.
| Barbara Henderson, Ph.D. Professor of Education San Francisco State University | ||
| Blythe Hinitz, Ed.D. Professor The College of New Jersey | Deborah L. Hintz-Knopf
| Alice Sterling Honig, Ph.D. Professor Emerita of Child Development Syracuse University | ||
Diane M. Horm, Ph.D.
| Peter Huffaker, M.B.A., M.A. Partner Child Care Results | Elisa A. Huss-Hage, M.Ed. Professor Owens Community College | ||
Jason Hustedt, Ph.D.
| Alissa Huth-Bocks, Ph.D. Associate Professor Eastern Michigan University | Mark S. Innocenti, Ph.D. Director Research & Evaluation, Center for Person with Disabilities Utah State University | ||
Iheoma Iruka, Ph.D.
| Jean Ispa, Ph.D. Professor University of Missouri | Carroll Izard, Ph.D. Trustees Distinguished Professor of Psychology University of Delaware | ||
Gera Jacobs, Ed.D. | Kristen Roorbach Jamison, Ph.D. Research Associate University of Virginia | Abigail Jewkes, Ph.D. Assistant Professor Hunter College, City University of New York | ||
| Lawrence J. Johnson, Ph.D. Dean, College of Education, Criminal Justice, and Human Services University of Cincinnati | Sharon Lynn Kagan, Ed.D. | Lilian G. Katz, Ph.D.
| ||
| Kristen Clarke Kellems, J.D. Research Associate University of Oregon | Margaret King, Ed.D Professor Emerita Ohio University | Elisa Klein, Ph.D. | ||
| Christopher Kloth Senior Consultant ChangeWorks of the Heartland | Mary Maguire Klute, Ph.D. Senior Director of Research and Evaluation Clayton Early Learning Institute | Lisa L. Knoche, Ph.D.
| ||
| Laura Kohn-Wood, Ph.D. Associate Professor Associate Chair and Program Director University of Miami, School of Education | Jon Korfmacher, Ph.D. Associate Professor Erikson Institute | Jonathan B. Kotch, M.D.
| ||
| Richard Lambert, Ph.D. Professor University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill | Faith Lamb-Parker, Ph.D. Professor Bank Street College of Education | Deborah J. Leong, Ph.D.
| ||
| Joan Lieber, Ph.D. Professor University of Maryland, College Park | Linda Likins National Director Devereux | Maura Linas, Ph.D.
| ||
Christopher Lloyd, Ph.D, LCSW
| Michael L. Lopez, Ph.D. | Janice Lovell, M.Ed. Higher Education Grant Director Tennessee State University | ||
| Duane Lowe, Ed.D. Adjunct Faculty California State University Long Beach | Julie Lumeng, M.D. Assistant Professor of Pediatrics University of Michigan | Catherine Lugg, Ph.D.
| ||
| Robert Lynch, Ph.D. Professor of Economics Washington College | Shelley Macy, M.A. | Mary Maggitti, Ph.D. Professor Emerita West Chester University | ||
| Katherine Magnuson, Ph.D. Associate Professor University of Wisconsin-Madison | Christopher A. Mallett, Ph.D., Esq.
| Patricia Manz, Ph.D. Associate Professor & Program Director of School Psychology Lehigh University | ||
| Rebecca A. Marcon, Ph.D. Professor University of North Florida | Sheila Marcus, M.D. | Smita Mathur, Ph.D. Assistant Professor University of South Florida Polytechnic | ||
| Wayne A. Mayfield, Ph.D. Research Associate University of Missouri | Rosemary McAuliffe
| Lisa McCabe, Ph.D. | ||
Robert B. McCall, Ph.D.
| Sandee McClowry, Ph.D., RN Professor New York University | Cindy McGaha, Ph.D. Associate Professor Appalachian State University | ||
| Robert McGivern, Ph.D. Professor San Diego State University | Lorraine McKelvey Ph.D.
| Elizabeth McLaren, Ed.D. Assistant Professor of Education Morehead State University | ||
Christine McWayne, Ph.D.
| Sara Michael-Luna, Ph.D. Assistant Professor Queens College-CUNY | Jon Miles, Ph.D. | ||
Alison Miller, Ph.D.
| Gayle Mindes, Ed.D. Professor of Education DePaul University | Kathleen M. Minke, Ph.D. Professor University of Delaware | ||
Cheryl Mitchell, Ph.D. | Simona Montanari, Ph.D. Assistant Professor California State University, Los Angeles | Bruce Moore, O.D.
| ||
Amanda Moreno, Ph.D. | April Morris, M.S. Partner Child Care Results | Jennifer Mosley Manager of Research Teaching Strategies | ||
| Kimberly Murphy Research Assistant University of Oregon | John Neisworth, Ph.D.
| Dana Nelson, Ph.D. Lecturer University of Washington | ||
Stacey Neuharth-Pritchett, Ph.D. | Julie Nicholson, Ph.D. Director, Leadership Program in Early Childhood Visiting Assistant Professor, Mills College | Patricia Nunley, Ed.D.
| ||
| Cindy O’Dell, Ed.D. Professor Cleveland State University | Sue Offutt, Ph.D.
| Leslie Oppenheimer, M.Ed. ECE Curriculum Coordinator University of Maryland | ||
Marissa Owsianik, M.A. | Mariela Paez, Ed.D Associate Professor Boston College | Gail Perry, Ph.D.
| ||
| Roger Phillips, Ph.D. Development Psychologist & Consultant | Ruth Piker, Ph.D. Assistant Professor California State University, Long Beach | Peggy Daly Pizzo, M.Ed. Senior Scholar Stanford University | ||
| Douglas Powell, Ph.D. Distinguished Professor Purdue University | Kristie Pretti-Frontczak, Ph.D. Professor Kent State University | Elizabeth Pungello, Ph.D.
| ||
| Amanda Quesenberry, Ph.D. Assistant Professor Illinois State University | C. Cybele Raver, Ph.D.
| Aisha Ray, Ph.D. Senior Vice President for Academic Affairs and Dean of Faculty Erikson Institute | ||
| Erin E. Reid, Ph.D. Postdoctoral Research Associate University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign | Wendy Robeson, Ed.D. Senior Research Scientist Wellesley Centers for Women Wellesley College | JoAnn Robinson, Ph.D. | ||
| James Rodriguez, Ph.D. Associate Professor California State University, Fullerton | Leigh Rohde, M.Ed.
| Yeon Sun Ro, Ph.D. Assistant Professor Penn State University | ||
Donald A. Rock, Ph.D. | M. Victoria Rodriguez, Ed.D.
| Lori Roggman, Ph.D. Professor Utah State University | ||
| Rene P. Rosenbaum, Ph.D. Associate Professor Michigan State University | Sharon Rosenkoetter, Ph.D. | Beth Rous, Ed.D.
| ||
| Susan Sandall Ph.D. Associate Professor, Special Education University of Washington | Rosa Milagros Santos, Ph.D.
| George Scarlett, Ph.D. Professor Tufts University | ||
Ilene Schwartz, Ph.D. Chair and Professor, Special Education Director, Haring Center
| Ronald Seifer, Ph.D. Professor and Research Director Brown University and E.P. Bradley Hospital | Michael Seliger, Ph.D. Dean Bronx Community College of the City University of New York | ||
| Rachel Schiffman, Ph.D., RN Professor and Associate Dean College of Nursing University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee | Jacqueline Shannon, Ph.D. | Susan M. Sheridan, Ph.D. Professor George Holmes University University of Nebraska-Lincoln | ||
Diana T. Slaughter-Defoe, Ph.D.
| Kathleen Snow Adjunct Professor | Susan Spieker, Ph.D. | ||
| Jane Squires, Ph.D. Professor Director of Center on Human Development University of Oregon | Ann M. Stacks, Ph.D. Assistant Professor Wayne State University | Martha D. Staker, RN, M.S., M.A.
| ||
| Prentice Starkey, Ph.D. Senior Project Director WestEd | Amanda Stein, Ph.D.
| Deborah Stipek, Ph.D. | ||
Billy Stokes, Ed.D. | Joseph J. Stowitschek, Ed.D.
| Paul Strand, Ph.D. Associate Professor Washington State University Tri-Cities | ||
| Susan Straub, M.S.W. Director The Read To Me Program | Dorothy Strickland, Ph.D.
| Kaveri Subrahmanyam, Ph.D. Professor of Psychology & Acting Chair California State University, Los Angeles | ||
| Jean Ann Summers, Ph.D. Research Professor University of Kansas | Mallary Swartz, Ph.D.
| Teri Talan, Ed.D. Associate Professor National-Louis University | ||
Angela Tookes
| Dana Tuller | Anne Turner-Henson, DSN, RN Professor University of Alabama at Birmingham, School of Nursing | ||
| Anne Turner-Henson, DSN, RN Professor University of Alabama at Birmingham, School of Nursing | Deborah Lowe Vandell, Ph.D.
| Sue Vartuli, Ph.D.
| ||
Joan I. Vondra, Ph.D.
| Alisha Wackerle-Hollman, Ph.D. Research Associate University of Minnesota | Dale Walker, Ph.D. Associate Research Professor Junpier Gardens Children’s Project University of Kansas | ||
Shavaun Wall, Ph.D.
| Kathleen Wallner-Allen, Ph.D. Senior Study Director Westat | Roberta B. Weber, Ph.D. Faculty Research Associate Oregon State University | ||
| Janette C. Wetsel, Ph.D. Associate Professor University of Central Oklahoma | Marcy Whitebook, Ph.D.
| M. Jeanne Wilcox, Ph.D. Professor and Director Infant Child Research Programs Arizona State University | ||
| Angela Wiley, Ph.D. Associate Professor University of Illinois | Jo Ann Williams, M.Ed. Executive Director Child Development, Inc. | Adam Winsler, Ph.D.
| ||
| Edyth J. Wheeler, Ph.D. Professor Towson University | Leanne Whiteside-Mansell, Ed.D.
| Linnie Green Wright, Ph.D. | ||
Noreen Yazejian, Ph.D.
| Meryl Yoches Doctoral Student University of Maryland, College Park | Hiro Yoshikawa, Ph.D. Professor of Education Harvard University | ||
Marlene Zepeda, Ph.D.
| Chun Zhang, Ph.D. Professor Fordham University |
[i] Barnett, W. (2002, September 13). The Battle Over Head Start: What the Research Shows. Presentation at a Science and Public Policy Briefing Sponsored by the Federation of Behavioral, Psychological, and Cognitive Sciences; Barnett, W. and Hustedt, J. (2005). Head Start's lasting benefits. Infants & Young Children, 18 (1): 16-24; Ludwig, J. and Miller, D. (2007). Does Head Start improve children's life chances? Evidence from a regression discontinuity design. The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 122 (1): 159-208.
[ii] Ludwig, J. and Miller, D. (2007). Does Head Start improve children's life chances? Evidence from a regression discontinuity design. The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 122 (1): 159-208.
[iii] Ibid.
[iv] Anderson, K.H., Foster, J.E., & Frisvold, D.E. (2009). Investing in health: The long-term impact of Head Start on smoking. Economic Inquiry, 48 (3), 587-602.
[v] Herman, A. (2005, Fall). Making a Difference in Head Start Families' Health Care. Dialog Briefs, 9(1): 4.
[vi] Garces, E., Thomas, D. and Currie, J. (2002, September). Longer-Term Effects of Head Start. American Economic Review, 92 (4): 999-1012
[vii] US Department of Health and Human Services. (2010, January). Head Start Impact Study Final Report - Executive Summary. The control group children were supposed to only consist of children who did not receive Head Start services, but a significant proportion of the control group received Head Start services anyway.
[viii] US Department of Health and Human Services. (2010, January). Head Start Impact Study Final Report; U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. Administration for Children and Families. (2004). Making a difference in the lives of infants and toddlers and their families: The impacts of Early Head Start, Volume I. Washington, DC.
[ix] Oyemade, U., V. Washington, and D. Gullo. (1989). The Relationship between Head Start Parental Involvement and the Economic and Social Self-Sufficiency of Head Start Families. Journal of Negro Education. 58, 1, 13.
[x] U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. Administration for Children and Families. (2004). Making a difference in the lives of infants and toddlers and their families: The impacts of Early Head Start, Volume II: Final technical report appendices. Washington, DC.
[xi] Ludwig, J. and Phillips, D. (2007). The Benefits and Costs of Head Start. Social Policy Report. 21 (3: 4); Meier, J. (2003, June 20). Interim Report. Kindergarten Readiness Study: Head Start Success. Preschool Service Department, San Bernardino County, California.
[xii] Heckman, J. (2010). Letter submitted to the National Commission on Fiscal Responsibility and Budget Reform.